Chubby's Pizza Customer Reviews

Anonymous 1

10/10 best pizza in town! Stays open late! Most amazing foods come from small little places like this! Don’t expect to sit down it’s quite small ! But I’d stand there for five hours just to get a slice!! Glad I’ve never had to wait long either their fast service!

2/6/2026

Keeley w

The cheese sticks are so sooo good, I got it with the garlic butter and pizza sauce, I 100% recommend

8/26/2024

Rick B

Greg, I worked with you back in 1998/1999 as a delivery driver. I had the teal Chrysler Lebaron convertible at the time. Glad you took over the business. You seem to be doing quite well down in Charleston, IL.

6/17/2022

Liz

The food is excellent and delicious every time. My only concern is that it is advertised to be open until 3 AM. However, there are times when we call for an order between 1 AM and 1:30 AM and no one answers or the phone is obviously left off the hook.

12/17/2021

Pam A

Great pizza!

12/24/2025

Logan

Great food in a timely manner. Delivery driver also gave my dog a treat which was pretty cool.

2/16/2024

Frances

Work overnight at SBLHS, and there aren't a lot of places open....but even if there were, I'd be getting Chubbys!!! You can fill up a crew, for a very reasonable price. Love it!!

2/11/2024

Greg

I’ve been down with Chubby’s since 1999! Easily my favorite pizza during my EIU days and I still hit it up every time I’m in Charleston.

7/26/2022

Jowana P

My friends and I have been loyal customers of Chubbys since 1998. My friend even tan all the way down Lincoln Avenue once to bring them back to us. True friend. The cheese sticks are literally the best option at 2am. Get the garlic dipping sauce! You won’t regret. Get the large. You won’t regret. EIU panthers were blessed the day Chubbys arrived!

6/16/2022

Terra

I feel like it would be a heck of a lot better if the people making it, cared. The pizza had so much potential if it were made with love. The dough was overworked and rubbery and extremely thin in places.. i will try again and hope for a different result..

1/3/2025

Jasper H

It’s the only pizza place in town that has an amazing tasting pizza in XL that doesn’t cost your whole paycheck. It’s also convenient when you want to do a late night order. Me & my husband both love their pizza & it’s our go-to.

10/8/2023

Bre T

Food was Amazing! Haven’t had it in a very long time! Definitely did not disappoint!!

12/2/2022

Laura P

I had the best deluxe pizza it was real cheesy just like Chicago style and it was real hot when delivered the driver was real nice l love Chubby pizzas their the best

7/4/2022